Check Cashing: an alternative to big banks?

February 23, 2010

in money,sponsors

I came across an article on NPR recently about check cashing companies as an alternative to banks.

As a personal finance writer, I have always considered check cashing companies to be predatory. They provide a service to people, but charge exorbitant rates, and are generally found in low income areas where people are more likely to be living paycheck to paycheck, and the few days it takes a bank to clear your cash might mean no food on the table. It seemed to me that they were taking advantage of people.

This article however, flipped that argument on its’ head by highlighting the fact that many of the 60 million Americans that use check cashing services* do so to avoid bank fees, overdraft fees, and figuring out when a check would hit their account. While there are fees involved in cashing a check the people interviewed by NPR said that they felt like they knew what they were getting versus banks who often charge fees or arrange payments so that customers are hit with fees-a large portion of their revenue.

Now I believe that many of those customers are choosing to avoid banks, which they distrust, and using check cashing as an alternative financial system. When you consider how long you may have to wait for a check to be available in your bank account, it does make sense.

pay-o-matic
Creative Commons License photo credit: TheTruthAbout…

Personally I have never used a check cashing service, and while I have had issues with a bank fees, I largely avoid them now thanks to smart money management. I do have a deep dislike for larger banks, because I feel they offer poor customer service, and in some ways act more predatory than a loan shark!

I prefer to bank with smaller, more customer oriented credit unions, and USAA who have stellar customer service. Have you used a check cashing service? If not, why not? If you have, why did you?

Kelly

Disclosure: * represents a sponsored link. I also have an ad with this company in my sidebar.

© 2010, Whalen Media LLC. All rights reserved. To repost or publish, please email Kelly.

About Kelly


Kelly Whalen is the founder of The Centsible Life, a blog where motherhood and money meet. Her goal is to help readers live well on less. Kelly is a mom to 4, and loves that she can stay at home with her kids, and still pursue her passions for writing, personal finance, and social media. You can often find her on twitter and Facebook talking money and motherhood.

Related Posts Plugin for WordPress, Blogger...
  • DFrancis

    Knowledge is King. I see some folks stating that they run from one bank to another on payday??? Why waste your time and gas? USAA’s App allows you to scan the check with your iPhone and then click to deposit it right there where you are – in your car, at work, at home, etc. And, the money is available at once. Duh…

  • http://littlebitthisnthat.blogspot.com/ Jennifer Y.

    Said my comment was too long, I guess I'm opinionated:)

    To the guy saying he has a distrust and distain for banks who have done him and his money wrong? Say what? I have had my own checking account since I was a teenager. Yes, you have to know your banks rules, like minimum balances and overdraft fees. And make sure you follow them the rules to avoid unecessary fees. I don't know his whole story, but seems like the only person doing his money wrong would be himself

    • http://intensedebate.com/people/CentsibleLife CentsibleLife

      Maybe he is doing himself a disservice, but I do see the other side of the coin. Maybe he can't handle a bank account.

  • http://littlebitthisnthat.blogspot.com/ Jennifer Y.

    Said my comment was too long, I guess I'm opinionated:)

    To the guy saying he has a distrust and distain for banks who have done him and his money wrong? Say what? I have had my own checking account since I was a teenager. Yes, you have to know your banks rules, like minimum balances and overdraft fees. And make sure you follow them the rules to avoid unecessary fees. I don't know his whole story, but seems like the only person doing his money wrong would be himself

    • http://www.thecentsiblelife.com/ Kelly Whalen

      Maybe he is doing himself a disservice, but I do see the other side of the coin. Maybe he can't handle a bank account.

  • http://littlebitthisnthat.blogspot.com/ Jennifer Y.

    I have never had the need to use a check cashing service. But, when you think about it, they are taking a (sometimes) large financial risk cashing these checks. I understand if they take a chunk. I think I remember seeing a news story or article about that recently?
    I have had to run from one bank to another on payday, though. When I was young, single, free, and poor (haha), I worked for a small ad firm downtown. They only issued handwritten payroll checks. The only way to get the money into my account that day was to use my lunch hour to run (take the bus) 15 blocks to the issuing bank and then back another 10 blocks to deposit the cash in my account. If banks are no longer doing this, then I would definitely see the need for more and more people to use these check cashing stores. .

    • http://intensedebate.com/people/CentsibleLife CentsibleLife

      It can be difficult to cash a check if it's from out of state, or a large amount. I'm pretty sure banks vary on the number.

      Part of having a bank account is building credit, so it may be that those people couldn't get an account since they have had issues previously. For a lot of people life is just paycheck to paycheck, and one small large expense can make their credit, their hard work, and their savings disappear.

  • http://littlebitthisnthat.blogspot.com/ Jennifer Y.

    I have never had the need to use a check cashing service. But, when you think about it, they are taking a (sometimes) large financial risk cashing these checks. I understand if they take a chunk. I think I remember seeing a news story or article about that recently?
    I have had to run from one bank to another on payday, though. When I was young, single, free, and poor (haha), I worked for a small ad firm downtown. They only issued handwritten payroll checks. The only way to get the money into my account that day was to use my lunch hour to run (take the bus) 15 blocks to the issuing bank and then back another 10 blocks to deposit the cash in my account. If banks are no longer doing this, then I would definitely see the need for more and more people to use these check cashing stores. .

    • http://www.thecentsiblelife.com/ Kelly Whalen

      It can be difficult to cash a check if it's from out of state, or a large amount. I'm pretty sure banks vary on the number.

      Part of having a bank account is building credit, so it may be that those people couldn't get an account since they have had issues previously. For a lot of people life is just paycheck to paycheck, and one small large expense can make their credit, their hard work, and their savings disappear.

      • Wilsonium

        While some banks do check your credit, the vast majority do not require good credit to open an account. However, many institutions use services like ChexSystems to verify whether our not you have mishandled your previous accounts. There is a difference. 

        For the bigger picture, I recently moved away from Wells Fargo Bank because of the new fee’s being implemented for account maintenance and debit card use. I am now with USAA for my local needs and I’ve had accounts with Navy Federal since I served in the military. Neither USAA or NFCU charge me any maintenance fees. 

        congratz on the new blog! Keep up the good work – Cheers

  • ferret

    Many banks won't cash right away, unless you have the same amount in deposits (to cover their risk) – bfj

  • ferret

    Many banks won't cash right away, unless you have the same amount in deposits (to cover their risk) – bfj

  • TJB

    I'm not fond of check cashing services because they can charge an upwards of 20% or more for the total amount of the check. Therefore I've never used them. I'm with USAA and the State Dept. Federal Credit Union and I don't pay any service fees with them. Not everyone can use either bank because you need affiliation, but there are similar banks out there.

    I thought that banks cashed checks as long as it was for their bank. Is that not the case any longer? At my job you can cash your check w/ Citibank the issuer of the check you just can't do it on the day the check is dated because of fraud issues they had, but you can do it the next day.

  • TJB

    I'm not fond of check cashing services because they can charge an upwards of 20% or more for the total amount of the check. Therefore I've never used them. I'm with USAA and the State Dept. Federal Credit Union and I don't pay any service fees with them. Not everyone can use either bank because you need affiliation, but there are similar banks out there.

    I thought that banks cashed checks as long as it was for their bank. Is that not the case any longer? At my job you can cash your check w/ Citibank the issuer of the check you just can't do it on the day the check is dated because of fraud issues they had, but you can do it the next day.

  • http://www.lifewithoutpink.com Tina

    Kelly thanks for stopping by my new blog and helping me kick it off. Your blog is awesome. I am learning so much from you. Hope to see you at an event soon!

  • http://www.lifewithoutpink.com/ Tina

    Kelly thanks for stopping by my new blog and helping me kick it off. Your blog is awesome. I am learning so much from you. Hope to see you at an event soon!

Previous post:

Next post: